Skip to Content

NY.gov Portal State Agency Listing

Translate | Disclaimer

Shopping For Auto Insurance

Optional Auto Insurance

Beyond the coverages required by law, most insurance companies offer a wide range of optional auto insurance coverages at additional cost. The most popular and valuable options are discussed here.

A. Bodily Injury Liability

Buying increased bodily injury liability limits is a good idea for consumers seeking to protect their assets in case of a lawsuit resulting from an auto accident. If you have assets that you wish to protect, you should seriously consider purchasing higher limits of bodily injury liability coverage -- $50,000/$100,000, $100,000/$300,000, $250,000/$500,000 or even higher. Some insurers offer policies with a combined single overall limit for both bodily injury liability and property damage liability, rather than separate limits, which would then pay up to a single maximum amount for all damages caused by one accident regardless of how many persons are injured (e.g., $100,000, $300,000 or $500,000).

B. Property Damage Liability

Although the requirement for third party property damage liability coverage is currently $10,000, many cars today are worth far more. Given the high cost of automobile replacement and/or repair, the purchase of property damage liability limits higher than the required minimum limit of $10,000 should be considered by insureds. Property damage limits of $15,000, $25,000, $50,000 and higher are generally available for an additional premium.

C. Additional PIP (No-Fault) Benefits

It is often smart to buy more No-Fault protection, over the basic $50,000 minimum coverage limit of No-Fault benefits required by law. Because of No-Fault’s cost-effective design, extended No-Fault benefits represent a relatively inexpensive option.

For a modest additional premium, optional coverages are available that will pay more than the required basic No-Fault benefits, explained in Minimum Auto Insurance Requirements. Consumers now have two choices:

Neither of these two additional No-Fault coverage options lengthens the three-year limit within which wage loss benefits are payable.

The availability of these No-Fault options makes optional medical payments coverage (see below) no longer as important as it had been, because that coverage (except for funeral expenses) responds only if No-Fault does not cover the situation or after No-Fault benefits, when applicable, are first exhausted.

D. Supplementary Uninsured/Underinsured Motorists (SUM) Coverage

As discussed in Minimum Auto Insurance Requirements one of the basic mandatory minimum coverages that comes with your auto policy is bodily injury protection against the negligent actions of an uninsured or hit-and-run motorist. You also have the option to expand this basic protection. For an additional premium, you can purchase higher coverage limits of Supplementary Uninsured/Underinsured Motorists (SUM) coverage of up to $250,000 per person per accident and $500,000 per accident, subject to the per person limit ($250,000/$500,000). Many insurers offer higher limits of SUM coverage. SUM coverage also provides coverage for accidents occurring out-of-state, which are not covered under the basic required Uninsured Motorists Coverage. However, the amount of SUM coverage may not exceed the bodily injury liability limits of your policy.

If SUM coverage has been purchased and you have an accident with another vehicle that is insured but has bodily injury liability limits lower than yours, or if such vehicle has no insurance at all, SUM coverage will be activated. The amounts paid under SUM by your policy up to its SUM limits will be reduced, or offset, by any amounts recovered from another party's auto insurance liability policy. Thus, if you are ever involved in an accident with other drivers, you can be sure that all family members who reside in your household are protected at least up to the amount of SUM coverage you have purchased from your own insurer.

E. Collision Coverage

With this optional insurance, your own insurer pays you, without regard to fault, for damage to your car caused by a collision with another car or any other object or your car overturning.

image of car collisionIf you do not have collision coverage, and your car is damaged in an accident where the other party is at least partially at fault, you may still recover all or part of the damages to your vehicle by making a claim against that other vehicle's property damage liability insurance coverage for the proportion of damages for which the other driver was at fault.


F. Comprehensive Coverage

Under comprehensive coverage, your insurer pays you, without regard to fault, for damage to your car from all causes, other than collision, such as theft (of the car itself or its parts), fire, flood, windstorm, glass breakage, vandalism, hitting or being hit by an animal, or by falling or flying objects.

If your car is stolen comprehensive coverage will also provide a certain amount per day specified in your policy for transportation expenses (rental car, public transportation, etc.). Generally, this coverage is provided until the time the company makes an offer to settle your claim.

Comprehensive and collision deductible options generally offered are $100, $200 (standard), $250, $500 and $1,000. Coverage may also be sold where the deductible does not apply to window glass damage. Remember, generally, you will not be paid more than the actual cash value of your car (i.e., what the car is worth) at the time of an accident, which takes depreciation into account. Some insurers also offer "replacement coverage" which will pay the cost to replace a vehicle with a brand new vehicle of the same make and model. This coverage usually applies in limited circumstances, for example, only up to one to three years after the car is purchased.

G. Medical Payments Coverage

This insurance pays, without regard to fault, medical expenses and funeral expenses for you and your passengers, if an accident occurs involving your car, up to its stated limits.

H. Accidental Death and Dismemberment (AD&D) Coverage

Some insurers offer coverage that will pay you, your family members, or other occupants of your car, under the terms of the policy, a set amount for certain serious injuries or death caused by an accident while in your car. These AD&D amounts are payable in addition to any amounts collected under the No-Fault, liability, or other parts of the policy.

I. Supplemental Spousal Liability Insurance

While your automobile liability insurance policy provides coverage for every passenger in your vehicle injured in an accident caused by the driver's negligence, it will most likely not provide any liability coverage when the injured passenger is your spouse. However, insurers are required to offer their policyholders the opportunity to purchase supplemental spousal liability coverage. This insurance covers the liability of an insured because of the death of or injury to his or her spouse for the liability insurance limits provided under the policy. You must request this additional coverage from your insurer and pay an additional premium for it unless your company is providing this coverage at no charge.

When you initially purchase insurance or at your policy renewal, your insurance company will be sending you notice of the availability of this coverage, an explanation of it and the additional premium that will be charged for it. Even if you do not purchase this optional coverage, a spouse is still eligible for No-fault benefits as discussed earlier.

J. Other Coverages

Other optional coverages available from some companies are Towing and Labor Coverage, Extended Transportation Coverage (Rental Reimbursement) and Mechanical Breakdown Coverage. You should contact your insurer, agent or broker to discuss whether it would be advisable for you to purchase them. Some additional coverage may only be offered when comprehensive and/or collision coverage is purchased on the insured vehicle.

Shopping for Auto Insurance | Next Topic | Consumers - Insurance Products