Skip to Content

Shopping For Auto Insurance

TELEPHONE NUMBERS AND WEBSITES OF AUTO INSURERS

image of telephone

The following is a list of toll-free telephone numbers and websites at which interested consumers may contact automobile insurance companies. The companies listed make up 90% of the private passenger automobile insurance marketplace (by premium volume) in New York State. Insurers indicated as “Agents Listed” may be found in a local telephone directory under their direct agencies.

Information on insurers not listed here may be obtained by contacting licensed insurance agents or brokers.

Company Name Telephone Number Website

21st Century Security Insurance Co.

877-310-5687

None

A-Central Insurance Co.

800-234-6926

www.nycm.com

Adriondack Insurance Exchange

866-992-4368

www.aie-ny.com

Allmerica Financial Alliance Insurance Co.

800-922-8427

www.hanover.com

Allstate Fire and Casualty Insurance Co.

800-ALLSTATE (800-255-7828)

www.allstate.com

Allstate Insurance Co.

800-ALLSTATE (800-255-7828)

www.Allstate.com

Amica Mutual Insurance Co.

800-242-6422

www.amica.com

Amica Property and Casualty

800-242-6422

www.amica.com

Chubb National Insurance Co.

866-324-8222

www.chubb.com/personal

Citizens Insurance Co. of America

800-922-8427

www.hanover.com

Country-Wide Insurance Co.

800-796-9288

www.cwico.com

Erie Insurance Co.

800-458-0811

www.erieinsurance.com

Esurance Insurance Co.

800-378-7262

www.esurance.com

Esurance Property and Casualty Insurance Co.

800-378-7262

www.esurance.com

Garrison Property and Casualty Insurance Co.

800-531-8722

www.usaa.com

GEICO General Insurance Co.

800-841-3000

www.geico.com

GEICO Indemnity Co.

800-841-3000

www.geico.com

Government Employees Insurance Co.

800-841-3000

www.geico.com

Hartford Accident and Indemnity Co.

800-423-6789

www.thehartford.com

Hartford Casualty Insurance Co.

800-423-6789

www.thehartford.com

Hartford Fire Insurance Co.

800-423-6789

www.thehartford.com

Hartford Insurance Co. of the Midwest

800-423-6789

www.thehartford.com

Hartford Underwriters Insurance Co.

800-423-6789

www.thehartford.com

Kemper Independence Insurance Co.

877-252-7878

www.kemper.com/wps/portal/KemperPreferred/Home

LM General Insurance Co.

888-323-4487

www.libertymutual.com

LM Insurance Corporation

888-323-4487

www.libertymutual.com

MAPFRE Insurance Co. of New York

855-627-3738

www.mapfreinsurance.com

Massachusetts Bay Insurance Co.

800-922-8427

www.hanover.com

Mercury Casualty Co.

800-987-6000

www.mercuryinsurance.com

Metropolitan Casualty Ins Co

888-675-6610

www.metlife.com

Metropolitan Group Property and Casualty Ins Co

888-675-6610

www.metlife.com

Metropolitan Property and Casualty Ins Co

888-675-6610

www.metlife.com

Mid-Century Insurance Co.

800-493-4917

www.Farmers.com

National General Assurance Co.

800-462-2123

www.NGIC.com

National General Insurance Online Inc

800-462-2123

www.NGIC.com

Nationwide Affinity Insurance Co. of America

877-669-6877

www.nationwide.com

Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co.   

877-669-6877

www.nationwide.com

Natiowide Affinity Ins Co.

877-669-6877

www.nationwide.com

New South Insurance Co.

800-462-2123

www.NGIC.com

New York Central Mutual Fire Ins Co

800-234-6926

www.nycm.com

Preferred Mutual Insurance Co.

800-333-7642

www.preferredmutual.com

Progressive Advanced Ins. Co.

800-776-4737

www.progressive.com

Progressive Casualty Ins. Co

800-776-4737

www.progressive.com

Progressive Max Ins. Co.

800-776-4737

www.progressive.com

Progressive Specialty Ins. Co

800-776-4737

www.progressive.com

Progressive Specialty Ins. Co.

800-776-4737

www.progressive.com

Property and Casualty Insurance Co. of Hartford

800-423-6789

www.thehartford.com

Republic Franklin Insurance Co.

800-556-1730

www.uticanational.com

Sentinel Insurance Co., Ltd

800-423-6789

www.thehartford.com

State Farm Fire and Casualty Co.

Agents Listed

www.statefarm.com

State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co.

Agents Listed

www.statefarm.com

The Hanover Insurance Co.

800-922-8427

www.hanover.com

Travelers Personal Insurance Co.

866-522-1338

www.travelers.com

Travelers Personal Security Insurance Co.

866-522-1338

www.travelers.com

Trumbull Insurance Co.

800-423-6789

www.thehartford.com

Twin City Fire Insurance Co.

800-423-6789

www.thehartford.com

United Services Automobile Association

800-531-8722

www.usaa.com

USAA Casualty Insurance Co.

800-531-8722

www.usaa.com

USAA General Indemnity Co.

800-531-8722

www.usaa.com

Utica Mutual Insurance Co.

800-556-1730

www.uticanational.com

Utica National Insurance Co. of Texas

800-556-1730

www.uticanational.com

 

Shopping for Auto Insurance |Consumers - Insurance Products | Insurers - Property Insurance

Updated 07/21/2016

 

Link to DFS Portal

About DFS

Contact DFS

Reports & Publications

Licensing

Laws and Regs

Connect With DFS

DFS Facebook page

Follow NYDFS on Twitter