Skip to Content

Comments Regarding the Proposed Virtual Currency Regulatory Framework

The New York State Department of Financial Services published a proposed virtual currency regulatory framework in the July 23, 2014 edition of the New York State Register. A revised proposed virtual currency regulatory framework was published in the February 25, 2015 edition of the New York State Register.

Links to all formal comments submitted during the comment periods are below. Comments are identified by the name signed to each comment. Where no signature was provided, the comment is labeled as unsigned.

Contact and transmittal information for commenters has been redacted. Otherwise, the text of each comment remains unaltered.

0 - 500 | 501 - 1000 | 1001 - 1500 | 1501 - 2000 | 2001 - 2500 | 2501 - 3000 | 3001 - 3500 | 3501 - 3748 | 3749 - 3781

Comment # (PDF) Date Submitted Name of Commenter

1501

10/17/2014 Dr. Justin P. Rohrer

1502

10/17/2014 Alex Bakaev

1503

10/17/2014 Robert Simmons

1504

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1505

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1506

10/17/2014 Will 

1507

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1508

10/17/2014 Ben Serebin

1509

10/17/2014 Ben Forsberg

1510

10/17/2014 Davey Wilkie

1511

10/17/2014 Dmitry Semiannikov

1512

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1513

10/17/2014 Cory Svensson

1514

10/17/2014 Michael Schmitt

1515

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1516

10/17/2014 Jarom Smith

1517

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1518

10/17/2014 Marina Tonkonogy

1519

10/17/2014 Milton A. Horst

1520

10/17/2014 Brandon MacDonald

1521

10/17/2014 Rachel Perron

1522

10/17/2014 Stephen Laskowski

1523

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1524

10/17/2014 Darryl Kerkeslager

1525

10/17/2014 L Marcus

1526

10/17/2014 Citizen of the Internet

1527

10/17/2014 Patti Macmillan

1528

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1529

10/17/2014 Tonya McDuell

1530

10/17/2014 Christopher Michaels

1531

10/17/2014 Chris Daft

1532

10/17/2014 Georgiy Treyvus

1533

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1534

10/17/2014 Aidan Murphey

1535

10/17/2014 Alan

1536

10/17/2014 Scott Hoff

1537

10/17/2014 Francis L. Knoll

1538

10/17/2014 Curry Taylor

1539

10/17/2014 C.B. Ko

1540

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1541

10/17/2014 David Needham

1542

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1543

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1544

10/17/2014 Glen Ihrig

1545

10/17/2014 Bryan Walston

1546

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1547

10/17/2014 Jay McIntyre

1548

10/17/2014 Aaron M. Ucko

1549

10/17/2014 David Tod Sigafoos

1550

10/17/2014 Brian Clifton

1551

10/17/2014 George Limitsios

1552

10/17/2014 Ralph

1553

10/17/2014 David McCarty

1554

10/17/2014 Justin Hobley

1555

10/17/2014 Joseph A. Gumbosky

1556

10/17/2014 Roberto Di Gennaro

1557

10/17/2014 Victor Rael

1558

10/17/2014 Reginald A. Carey

1559

10/17/2014 Robert Ghost

1560

10/17/2014 Michael S. Keller

1561

10/17/2014 Michael Hawk

1562

10/17/2014 Jeffery Hoffman

1563

10/17/2014 Ryan

1564

10/17/2014 Soni Lasso

1565

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1566

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1567

10/17/2014 Patricio Carrasco

1568

10/17/2014 Tara Mulski

1569

10/17/2014 Jan Lucanus

1570

10/17/2014 Ai Hannan

1571

10/17/2014 Jeff Woods

1572

10/17/2014 Michael Sheldon

1573

10/17/2014 Brian Basham

1574

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1575

10/17/2014 Duncan M

1576

10/17/2014 Cynthia Starr

1577

10/17/2014 Alan Heirich

1578

10/17/2014 Tommy Bozeman

1579

10/17/2014 Jim R Jones

1580

10/17/2014 Riley Hickman

1581

10/17/2014 Alex 

1582

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1583

10/17/2014 M  Hinish

1584

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1585

10/17/2014 John Wilbur

1586

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1587

10/17/2014 Gloriamarie Amalfitano

1588

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1589

10/17/2014 Arlo 

1590

10/17/2014 Martin Baclija

1591

10/17/2014 Charles Summers

1592

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1593

10/17/2014 Rich Siegel

1594

10/17/2014 Serge Akhmatdinov

1595

10/17/2014 Robert Bradshaw

1596

10/17/2014 Robert Clark

1597

10/17/2014 Luis Medina

1598

10/17/2014 Felix Bunke

1599

10/17/2014 Foster Winter

1600

10/17/2014 Steve Spieckerman

1601

10/17/2014 Jose Humberto Araque Meza

1602

10/17/2014 Pavel Mikoloski

1603

10/17/2014 Eric J. Christeson

1604

10/17/2014 William.B Ellern

1605

10/17/2014 Gordon Parker III

1606

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1607

10/17/2014 Daniel Reckers

1608

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1609

10/17/2014 Steven A Chan

1610

10/17/2014 Jacob Rufer

1611

10/17/2014 Ron West

1612

10/17/2014 Andrés Delgado

1613

10/17/2014 Brayden Banks

1614

10/17/2014 Ian Finley

1615

10/17/2014 Doug Walter

1616

10/17/2014 Bruce Rose

1617

10/17/2014 O. Hinds

1618

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1619

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1620

10/17/2014 Nikko Williard

1621

10/17/2014 Cameron Krout

1622

10/17/2014 Thomas J Ackermann

1623

10/17/2014 Michael Kennedy

1624

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1625

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1626

10/17/2014 Daniel Howell

1627

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1628

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1629

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1630

10/17/2014 Olyvier Bilodeau

1631

10/17/2014 Steven J. Hill

1632

10/17/2014 Phil Budne

1633

10/17/2014 Chris Zumbrunn

1634

10/17/2014 Nicholas A. Hollander

1635

10/17/2014 John Leone

1636

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1637

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1638

10/17/2014 Thorn

1639

10/17/2014 Joe Klemmer

1640

10/17/2014 Bill Jamisin

1641

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1642

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1643

10/17/2014 JimCarroll

1644

10/17/2014 Javier Anguiano

1645

10/17/2014 Blake VanValkenburg

1646

10/17/2014 Shawn Maxim

1647

10/17/2014 Sean Lundquist

1648

10/17/2014 David Xia

1649

10/17/2014 Victor 

1650

10/17/2014 Ameen Wahba

1651

10/17/2014 Ann Getman

1652

10/17/2014 Barry Lerner

1653

10/17/2014 James Plotts

1654

10/17/2014 Adam G. Van Kirk

1655

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1656

10/17/2014 Unsigned

1657

10/17/2014 Karl S. Schumaker

1658

10/17/2014 Christian Holder

1659

10/17/2014 Robert Esplin

1660

10/18/2014 Robert Hewlett

1661

10/18/2014 Mike A. Segal

1662

10/18/2014 Nathan Arthur

1663

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1664

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1665

10/18/2014 Michael

1666

10/18/2014 Philip Shook

1667

10/18/2014 Carlos Cabral

1668

10/18/2014 Christian Straight

1669

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1670

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1671

10/18/2014 David Levine

1672

10/18/2014 Luke

1673

10/18/2014 Lindsay MacVean

1674

10/18/2014 Lynnie Neal

1675

10/18/2014 Michael Elkevizth

1676

10/18/2014 Tony Zito

1677

10/18/2014 Richard

1678

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1679

10/18/2014 Lindsay Macvean

1680

10/18/2014 Donovan Jefferson

1681

10/18/2014 Michael Collins

1682

10/18/2014 Neil Manson

1683

10/18/2014 Jay Libove

1684

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1685

10/18/2014 Mark L. Williams

1686

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1687

10/18/2014 Akash Kumar Sharma

1688

10/18/2014 Harvey Fox

1689

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1690

10/18/2014 Justin Aplin

1691

10/18/2014 Harvey 

1692

10/18/2014 Daniel Rong

1693

10/18/2014 Tortorici

1694

10/18/2014 Sean J Mahoney

1695

10/18/2014 Lorri Megonigal

1696

10/18/2014 Brett Anderson

1697

10/18/2014 Peter Buckles

1698

10/18/2014 Iain Buchanan

1699

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1700

10/18/2014 Gerald Carpenter

1701

10/18/2014 Nick Malchoff

1702

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1703

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1704

10/18/2014 Caleb Malchik

1705

10/18/2014 Fred Harth

1706

10/18/2014 Ty Satrang

1707

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1708

10/18/2014 David George

1709

10/18/2014 Pedro Muñoz

1710

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1711

10/18/2014 Joel Luellwitz

1712

10/18/2014 Phil Kritzman

1713

10/18/2014 Matthew Gordon

1714

10/18/2014 Jesse

1715

10/18/2014 Jen Helsby

1716

10/18/2014  Cohen

1717

10/18/2014 Heath Wyld

1718

10/18/2014 Mattias Pavlina

1719

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1720

10/18/2014 Gretchen Miller

1721

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1722

10/18/2014 Antoinio White

1723

10/18/2014 Michael Haag

1724

10/18/2014 Michael Gnat

1725

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1726

10/18/2014 Ian Koustas

1727

10/18/2014 Wesley Wu

1728

10/18/2014 Lisa LeBlanc

1729

10/18/2014 Chris Ewing

1730

10/18/2014 David Mutia

1731

10/18/2014 Darren

1732

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1733

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1734

10/18/2014 Taylor Hellewell

1735

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1736

10/18/2014 Scott Francis

1737

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1738

10/18/2014 Dan Cunningham

1739

10/18/2014 Tim O

1740

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1741

10/18/2014 Steve Parsons

1742

10/18/2014 Tyler Mills

1743

10/18/2014 Guy Greenwood

1744

10/18/2014 Michael Whitcher

1745

10/18/2014 Angela Stankowski

1746

10/18/2014 Austin 

1747

10/18/2014 ALR

1748

10/18/2014 Todd Sidwell

1749

10/18/2014 Marshall S. Soul

1750

10/18/2014 Sandra M

1751

10/18/2014 Mark

1752

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1753

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1754

10/18/2014 Robert Randall

1755

10/18/2014 Tara Guidry

1756

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1757

10/18/2014 Charles Neal

1758

10/18/2014 Rhona Mahony

1759

10/18/2014 Joe Kent

1760

10/18/2014 Christian Gunther

1761

10/18/2014 Shawn Yeager

1762

10/18/2014 Rafael Lopez

1763

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1764

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1765

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1766

10/18/2014 Eric Young

1767

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1768

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1769

10/18/2014 Paul Deis

1770

10/18/2014 Benjamin Peter Foot

1771

10/18/2014 Gary Rosende

1772

10/18/2014 Chris Lish

1773

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1774

10/18/2014 Bob Bishop

1775

10/18/2014 Zach Williams

1776

10/18/2014 Javier Fonseca

1777

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1778

10/18/2014 MacMaster

1779

10/18/2014 Nicholas Lau

1780

10/18/2014 Yedidya Feldblum

1781

10/18/2014 Andrew Kennedy

1782

10/18/2014 Garry Taylor

1783

10/18/2014 Jessica Phillips

1784

10/18/2014 Jonathan Mckie

1785

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1786

10/18/2014 Dan Kutscher

1787

10/18/2014 George Arthur Veghte

1788

10/18/2014 Lia 

1789

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1790

10/18/2014 Chris Antaki

1791

10/18/2014 E. Lynk

1792

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1793

10/18/2014 Caleb Nymeyer

1794

10/18/2014 Bradford Solomon

1795

10/18/2014 Carl Nelson

1796

10/18/2014 Eli Bildirici

1797

10/18/2014 Qaisra Shakir

1798

10/18/2014 Jolene Darnold

1799

10/18/2014 Qaisra Shakir

1800

10/18/2014 Jonathan Ingold

1801

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1802

10/18/2014 Danny Ames

1803

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1804

10/18/2014 Konstantin Linskiy

1805

10/18/2014 Anthony A. Karian

1806

10/18/2014 Danny Mitsios

1807

10/18/2014 John Overstreet

1808

10/18/2014 Jeremy Goemaat

1809

10/18/2014 Conley Moorhous

1810

10/18/2014 Jordan May

1811

10/18/2014 Andrew Costax

1812

10/18/2014 Christian Sasso

1813

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1814

10/18/2014 Norman Andrews

1815

10/18/2014 Jed

1816

10/18/2014 John C. Woodward

1817

10/18/2014 David Caudill

1818

10/18/2014 Dominic Sarria-Wiley

1819

10/18/2014 Bruce Burns

1820

10/18/2014 Matthew Ball

1821

10/18/2014 Kevin Neal

1822

10/18/2014 Keavon Chambers

1823

10/18/2014 Jacob Ultzhoffer

1824

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1825

10/18/2014 Saad Mir

1826

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1827

10/18/2014 Todd Megee

1828

10/18/2014 Shelli R. Maylin

1829

10/18/2014 Jeff Hoffman

1830

10/18/2014 Mr Dylan X Kelly

1831

10/18/2014 Andrew Y. Yoon

1832

10/18/2014 Fernando Ducloux

1833

10/18/2014 David Biczo

1834

10/18/2014 Sherif Botros

1835

10/18/2014 Jean-Pierre 

1836

10/18/2014 Michael F. Jones

1837

10/18/2014 Rob Lucke

1838

10/18/2014 Rainey Reitman

1839

10/18/2014 Michael D Adams

1840

10/18/2014 William Burke

1841

10/18/2014 AA

1842

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1843

10/18/2014 Tom Lieber

1844

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1845

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1846

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1847

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1848

10/18/2014 Enel Woods

1849

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1850

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1851

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1852

10/18/2014 Radu Fetila

1853

10/18/2014 Red Black

1854

10/18/2014 Pablo Grillo

1855

10/18/2014 Rod Smith

1856

10/18/2014 James Eddington

1857

10/18/2014 Brian Gadberry

1858

10/18/2014 James Gordon Dean

1859

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1860

10/18/2014 Adi Kamdar

1861

10/18/2014 Leanne Claire

1862

10/18/2014 Jan Porter

1863

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1864

10/18/2014 Elias Zamaria

1865

10/18/2014 Ronald Long

1866

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1867

10/18/2014 Kyle Crookshank

1868

10/18/2014 Arthur Cookman

1869

10/18/2014 Dennis

1870

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1871

10/18/2014 Gabriel

1872

10/18/2014 Jeromy Shald

1873

10/18/2014 Martin Jebb

1874

10/18/2014 Ian Nicholson

1875

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1876

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1877

10/18/2014 Adam 

1878

10/18/2014 James Fitzgerald

1879

10/18/2014 Stephen Ferrari

1880

10/18/2014 Tracy Weiss

1881

10/18/2014 Erik Jensen

1882

10/18/2014 Tom Behrendt

1883

10/18/2014 James Focht

1884

10/18/2014 Derek Shuman

1885

10/18/2014 Jochen Spalding

1886

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1887

10/18/2014 Riph van den Assum

1888

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1889

10/18/2014 Ansgar Kessler

1890

10/18/2014 Donald Wright

1891

10/18/2014 David Chandler

1892

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1893

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1894

10/18/2014 Nolan Roberson

1895

10/18/2014 Carlos Herkt

1896

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1897

10/18/2014 William Linch, Jr.

1898

10/18/2014 Jon Deneweth

1899

10/18/2014 Antoine Alary

1900

10/18/2014 Andreas Gwilt

1901

10/18/2014 Ravi Prakash

1902

10/18/2014 Glenn 

1903

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1904

10/18/2014 Seth Maxson

1905

10/18/2014 EB Schwartz

1906

10/18/2014 Kenneth Ruby

1907

10/18/2014 Stan Kuo

1908

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1909

10/18/2014 Rich Painter

1910

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1911

10/18/2014 Dennis Wright

1912

10/18/2014 Eric des Courtis

1913

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1914

10/18/2014 Michael Amirault

1915

10/18/2014 Jacob Holt

1916

10/18/2014 Scott Grayson

1917

10/18/2014 Jean Lindgren

1918

10/18/2014 Mikhail Evtushenko

1919

10/18/2014 Katherine Kovacs

1920

10/18/2014 Tijl Deconynck

1921

10/18/2014 Richard Decal

1922

10/18/2014 Pirooz Daneshmandi

1923

10/18/2014 A. Sprakelaar

1924

10/18/2014 Daniel Taylor

1925

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1926

10/18/2014 Walker Traylor

1927

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1928

10/18/2014 Mara Cohen

1929

10/18/2014 Mara Cohen

1930

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1931

10/18/2014 Marcus Smith

1932

10/18/2014 Bob Stapp

1933

10/18/2014 Mara Cohen

1934

10/18/2014 James Vermillion

1935

10/18/2014 Klaus Lichtenwalder

1936

10/18/2014 Jeston Tigchon

1937

10/18/2014 Alexander

1938

10/18/2014 Quentin 

1939

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1940

10/18/2014 Anthony Bartoletti

1941

10/18/2014 David Murray

1942

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1943

10/18/2014 Caleb Evans

1944

10/18/2014 Mainframe Magazine

1945

10/18/2014 Keith Styles

1946

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1947

10/18/2014 Grant Johnson

1948

10/18/2014 Casey Stone

1949

10/18/2014 Michael Griffith

1950

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1951

10/18/2014 Natasha Himmelman

1952

10/18/2014 Clayton Fuller

1953

10/18/2014 Alexander Henrich

1954

10/18/2014 Hans 

1955

10/18/2014 John Collyer

1956

10/18/2014 Diego Ramírez 

1957

10/18/2014 Beverly Bassett

1958

10/18/2014 Benoit Mortier

1959

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1960

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1961

10/18/2014 David Linebarger

1962

10/18/2014 Keelin FitzGerald

1963

10/18/2014 Tim Hughes

1964

10/18/2014 Michael Roseberry

1965

10/18/2014 Dr. Jameson

1966

10/18/2014 Deathe Davis

1967

10/18/2014 Dr George W Gerrity

1968

10/18/2014 Robert Whitney

1969

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1970

10/18/2014 Zoltan K.

1971

10/18/2014 Reinhard Prix

1972

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1973

10/18/2014 Philippe S.

1974

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1975

10/18/2014 Kiriakos Tsourapas

1976

10/18/2014 Sofia Meyen

1977

10/18/2014 Jonathan Carman

1978

10/18/2014 Spencer Hersom

1979

10/18/2014 Paolo Fattiboni

1980

10/18/2014 Chung Chang

1981

10/18/2014 Randell Jesup

1982

10/18/2014 Bryan Hiestand

1983

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1984

10/18/2014 Gabriel Borsodi

1985

10/18/2014 Barbara Müller

1986

10/18/2014 Morten Hassel 

1987

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1988

10/18/2014 Mark Hodgen

1989

10/18/2014 David Neilan

1990

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1991

10/18/2014 Unsigned

1992

10/18/2014 Brandon Zehm

1993

10/18/2014 Tom Krickl

1994

10/18/2014 Greg Nelson

1995

10/18/2014 Nicola Johnson

1996

10/18/2014 Eric Downes

1997

10/18/2014 Jim Willeke

1998

10/18/2014 Jaime Morell Alcover

1999

10/18/2014 Annie Rife

2000

10/18/2014 Unsigned

Previous page | Next page

Updated 06/24/2015

 

Link to DFS Portal

About DFS

Contact DFS

Reports & Publications

Licensing

Laws and Regs

Connect With DFS

DFS Facebook page

Follow NYDFS on Twitter