Skip to Content

Comments Regarding the Proposed Virtual Currency Regulatory Framework

The New York State Department of Financial Services published a proposed virtual currency regulatory framework in the July 23, 2014 edition of the New York State Register. A revised proposed virtual currency regulatory framework was published in the February 25, 2015 edition of the New York State Register.

Links to all formal comments submitted during the comment periods are below. Comments are identified by the name signed to each comment. Where no signature was provided, the comment is labeled as unsigned.

Contact and transmittal information for commenters has been redacted. Otherwise, the text of each comment remains unaltered.

0 - 500 | 501 - 1000 | 1001 - 1500 | 1501 - 2000 | 2001 - 2500 | 2501 - 3000 | 3001 - 3500 | 3501 - 3748 | 3749 - 3781

Comment # (PDF) Date Submitted Name of Commenter

2001

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2002

10/18/2014 Adam Pine

2003

10/18/2014 Richard Niescior

2004

10/18/2014 Jack Calverley

2005

10/18/2014 R J Beazley

2006

10/18/2014 C.R.S.

2007

10/18/2014 Willy Banderman

2008

10/18/2014 Chris Clark

2009

10/18/2014 Dave

2010

10/18/2014 Thierry Marianne

2011

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2012

10/18/2014 Elisabeth Renee Nath

2013

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2014

10/18/2014 Raymond Fellers

2015

10/18/2014 Dominik Pintarić

2016

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2017

10/18/2014 Tom Farrow

2018

10/18/2014 Francesco Chinnici

2019

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2020

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2021

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2022

10/18/2014 Paul M Edwards

2023

10/18/2014 Michael W Evans

2024

10/18/2014 Martin Ström

2025

10/18/2014 Johannes Schwab

2026

10/18/2014 Ryan Taylor

2027

10/18/2014 Carl Peterson

2028

10/18/2014 Hrvoje Katusic

2029

10/18/2014 Mark Tipton

2030

10/18/2014 Thorbjørn Lindeijer

2031

10/18/2014 James Conroy-Finn

2032

10/18/2014 R. A. Utley

2033

10/18/2014 Adam Ralph

2034

10/18/2014 Frederic Eger

2035

10/18/2014 AG Gilmore

2036

10/18/2014 Geoff

2037

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2038

10/18/2014 Ð

2039

10/18/2014 Emile Priller

2040

10/18/2014 John W. Greathead

2041

10/18/2014 Rob

2042

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2043

10/18/2014 Juan Montero

2044

10/18/2014 Wesley Rutledge

2045

10/18/2014 Anna Marrie

2046

10/18/2014 Ben Boaz

2047

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2048

10/18/2014 Bor Svab

2049

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2050

10/18/2014 Sander Devrieze

2051

10/18/2014 Jace Ellis

2052

10/18/2014 Cliff Mitchell

2053

10/18/2014 Dr. Unger, A.

2054

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2055

10/18/2014 Gage Hutchins

2056

10/18/2014 Martin 'Helios' Steigerwald

2057

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2058

10/18/2014 Miguel Delgado

2059

10/18/2014 S Jahangeer

2060

10/18/2014 P.X

2061

10/18/2014 Me

2062

10/18/2014 Robert Turner

2063

10/18/2014 Jose Ordinas Lewis

2064

10/18/2014 Ralph Tuscher

2065

10/18/2014 Henrik Iacobæus

2066

10/18/2014 Sean Kelley

2067

10/18/2014 Ed Light

2068

10/18/2014 Colin Smyth

2069

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2070

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2071

10/18/2014 Joyce Grimshaw

2072

10/18/2014 Nick Cripps

2073

10/18/2014 J. Lee

2074

10/18/2014 Hugh Graham

2075

10/18/2014 Trevor Bending

2076

10/18/2014 René Ladan

2077

10/18/2014 Emiliano Piazza

2078

10/18/2014 Rubin

2079

10/18/2014 Joel Harris

2080

10/18/2014 Olaf 'Rhialto' Seibert

2081

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2082

10/18/2014 Edgar Rios

2083

10/18/2014 Jason Fourier

2084

10/18/2014 Henk ter Heide

2085

10/18/2014 Jose Emiliano Perez

2086

10/18/2014 Phil Payton

2087

10/18/2014 Xavier Mendez

2088

10/18/2014 John McNiel

2089

10/18/2014 Peter Vachuska

2090

10/18/2014 Reza Hiwa

2091

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2092

10/18/2014 Edil Justiniano

2093

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2094

10/18/2014 Bill Kays

2095

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2096

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2097

10/18/2014 Peter Polacik

2098

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2099

10/18/2014 Brandon M. Sergent

2100

10/18/2014 Simon K

2101

10/18/2014 Terry

2102

10/18/2014 Hor Jiun Shyong

2103

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2104

10/18/2014 ssteiner

2105

10/18/2014 Robert Rogers

2106

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2107

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2108

10/18/2014 Alessandro Bertolla

2109

10/18/2014 Christian Hartleben

2110

10/18/2014 Mickey Dekkers

2111

10/18/2014 Clark Oehler

2112

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2113

10/18/2014 David Daskiewich

2114

10/18/2014 Duncan Young

2115

10/18/2014 Andrew Dominic

2116

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2117

10/18/2014 Olga Alexander

2118

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2119

10/18/2014 John D. Bartram

2120

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2121

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2122

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2123

10/18/2014 Nate Houk

2124

10/18/2014 Joseph O'Connor

2125

10/18/2014 Kenneth Machere

2126

10/18/2014 Michael Wichman

2127

10/18/2014 Charles L. Nelson

2128

10/18/2014 T.K. Stackhouse

2129

10/18/2014 Claude

2130

10/18/2014 Sebastian Jylanki

2131

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2132

10/18/2014 Daniel Harrington

2133

10/18/2014 Kishan Gupta

2134

10/18/2014 Freddie L. King

2135

10/18/2014 Robert Wales

2136

10/18/2014 Andre Thebeau

2137

10/18/2014 Cezary Nietupski

2138

10/18/2014 John Hartman

2139

10/18/2014 Joseph O'Connor

2140

10/18/2014 Ashwin Purohit

2141

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2142

10/18/2014 Jason Ross

2143

10/18/2014 Tom Bengaff

2144

10/18/2014 John Pinheiro

2145

10/18/2014 David Lundin

2146

10/18/2014 Greg Byrd

2147

10/18/2014 David Fournier

2148

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2149

10/18/2014 Kenrick Jackson

2150

10/18/2014 Alan Smithee

2151

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2152

10/18/2014 Pieter King

2153

10/18/2014 Tai Jarman

2154

10/18/2014 James Harig

2155

10/18/2014 Seth Webster

2156

10/18/2014 Marek Zielinski

2157

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2158

10/18/2014 Jeff Byers

2159

10/18/2014 Dan Romain

2160

10/18/2014 Mike Laird

2161

10/18/2014 N. F. Martin

2162

10/18/2014 John O'Donnell

2163

10/18/2014 Brendan Jaffer

2164

10/18/2014 Sussi Vilsø

2165

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2166

10/18/2014 Jerrold Kaplan

2167

10/18/2014 Zoey Jacobsen

2168

10/18/2014 Guilherme Salgado

2169

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2170

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2171

10/18/2014 Douglas

2172

10/18/2014 Peter Stiles

2173

10/18/2014 David Bradley

2174

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2175

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2176

10/18/2014 D Hill

2177

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2178

10/18/2014 Tom Pendleton

2179

10/18/2014 Tames McTigue

2180

10/18/2014 Marshall Neipert

2181

10/18/2014 Mark Coleman

2182

10/18/2014 Ed Barrows

2183

10/18/2014 Mark Coleman

2184

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2185

10/18/2014 Owen L.

2186

10/18/2014 Mike Wheeler

2187

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2188

10/18/2014 James L. King III

2189

10/18/2014 Roel Palmaers

2190

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2191

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2192

10/18/2014 Kit Mason

2193

10/18/2014 rv

2194

10/18/2014 Stephen

2195

10/18/2014 Mansur Johnson

2196

10/18/2014 Krishna White

2197

10/18/2014 Richard Naylor

2198

10/18/2014 Susan Madorsky

2199

10/18/2014 Bryan Rushing

2200

10/18/2014 Kate Anderson

2201

10/18/2014 Ronald R Faulkner Jr

2202

10/18/2014 Tony Scott

2203

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2204

10/18/2014 Santiago Bosio

2205

10/18/2014 Yozen Hernandez

2206

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2207

10/18/2014 Paul M Keefe

2208

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2209

10/18/2014 Samir Rawani

2210

10/18/2014 John P. Ragan

2211

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2212

10/18/2014 Johan Sellström

2213

10/18/2014 Dustin Watson

2214

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2215

10/18/2014 David Fiore

2216

10/18/2014 Shawn M Thomas

2217

10/18/2014 Teri Bloom

2218

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2219

10/18/2014 Nathan Ignatz

2220

10/18/2014 Robert M Carroll

2221

10/18/2014 Daniel Clendening

2222

10/18/2014 Charles Antonelli

2223

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2224

10/18/2014 Claudio J. Moreta

2225

10/18/2014 Steve Crow

2226

10/18/2014 Elizabeth Marsh

2227

10/18/2014 Marco Barnà

2228

10/18/2014 J M Zirger

2229

10/18/2014 Phillip Ferguson

2230

10/18/2014 Derek Hauffe

2231

10/18/2014 S. Fava

2232

10/18/2014 Steve Jackson

2233

10/18/2014 Alfredo Lusa

2234

10/18/2014 Shane Abel

2235

10/18/2014 Manuel Flury

2236

10/18/2014 Chris Rogers

2237

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2238

10/18/2014 Lemuel Stigler

2239

10/18/2014 Peter Schultz

2240

10/18/2014 Richard J. Wilcox

2241

10/18/2014 Raul Argueta

2242

10/18/2014 Gina Mindock

2243

10/18/2014 Will Maddrey

2244

10/18/2014 John Doe

2245

10/18/2014 Mark Bernard

2246

10/18/2014 Mr. R Mala

2247

10/18/2014 Adam Pawlik

2248

10/18/2014 James Stuhlmacher

2249

10/18/2014 Antonio Moroni

2250

10/18/2014 V. Post

2251

10/18/2014 John Butler

2252

10/18/2014 Bill Toole

2253

10/18/2014 Jeff Trickett

2254

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2255

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2256

10/18/2014 Jenefer Ellingston

2257

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2258

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2259

10/18/2014 Thomas Pfeiffer

2260

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2261

10/18/2014 John R. Bashinski

2262

10/18/2014 Pierre Brienne

2263

10/18/2014 Jim Siderits

2264

10/18/2014 Kendall Lovett

2265

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2266

10/18/2014 Doug Wetzel

2267

10/18/2014 Christopher Vagnetoft

2268

10/18/2014 Glenn Howard

2269

10/18/2014 Roger Haas

2270

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2271

10/18/2014 Andre Croy

2272

10/18/2014 Kathleen Wroblewski

2273

10/18/2014 Robert Siegel

2274

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2275

10/18/2014 Frederico Rozeira

2276

10/18/2014 Timothy Reaves

2277

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2278

10/18/2014 Sara Grande

2279

10/18/2014 Mike Osmon

2280

10/18/2014 Sherri A. Marquis

2281

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2282

10/18/2014 Pedro

2283

10/18/2014 Kelly McRae

2284

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2285

10/18/2014 Damon Chavez

2286

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2287

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2288

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2289

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2290

10/18/2014 Michael Riser

2291

10/18/2014 Boudewijn Kranendonk

2292

10/18/2014 Ryan Bradley

2293

10/18/2014 Adam Wishneusky

2294

10/18/2014 Matthew Baya

2295

10/18/2014 Heriberto J. Rangel N.

2296

10/18/2014 Arthur Kaliski

2297

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2298

10/18/2014 Scott Merker

2299

10/18/2014 D.J. Granfors

2300

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2301

10/18/2014 Sean Nowlan

2302

10/18/2014 Josue Romero

2303

10/18/2014 Jeffrey Arto

2304

10/18/2014 Rick Craven

2305

10/18/2014 J. Stark

2306

10/18/2014 Gord Tomlin

2307

10/18/2014 Karl Schneider

2308

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2309

10/18/2014 Nikolas A

2310

10/18/2014 Cameron Hart

2311

10/18/2014 Edward R. Garcia

2312

10/18/2014 Attel

2313

10/18/2014 Jeffrey Brubaker

2314

10/18/2014 Alex

2315

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2316

10/18/2014 Gerard Cronin

2317

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2318

10/18/2014 Julie Levine

2319

10/18/2014 Nick Lavely

2320

10/18/2014 James D. Wilson

2321

10/18/2014 Alexander Dietrich

2322

10/18/2014 Timelord

2323

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2324

10/18/2014 Joel Caruso

2325

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2326

10/18/2014 MK Grindstaff

2327

10/18/2014 Bobby Moss

2328

10/18/2014 Adam Moon

2329

10/18/2014 WiNoJoE

2330

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2331

10/18/2014 Benjamin Blank

2332

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2333

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2334

10/18/2014 Dominic Comerford

2335

10/18/2014 Daniel Gitau

2336

10/18/2014 Wayne Stinson

2337

10/18/2014 Dan

2338

10/18/2014 Jim Culbertson

2339

10/18/2014 Ian Foote

2340

10/18/2014 Greg S.

2341

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2342

10/18/2014 Matthew Ashe

2343

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2344

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2345

10/18/2014 Jeffrey Wubbenhorst

2346

10/18/2014 Chris Cleary

2347

10/18/2014 Adam S. Winter

2348

10/18/2014 Luke

2349

10/18/2014 Pierre Sucre

2350

10/18/2014 Graham Webster-Gardiner

2351

10/18/2014 Miguel Vidal

2352

10/18/2014 Alex Lapinski

2353

10/18/2014 Joan Chandley

2354

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2355

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2356

10/18/2014 Dr. Gene McNay

2357

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2358

10/18/2014 Andrea Saunders

2359

10/18/2014 Ian Miller

2360

10/18/2014 Heather Brooks

2361

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2362

10/18/2014 Jeff Hayes

2363

10/18/2014 Robert Halbert

2364

10/18/2014 Kevin Richardson

2365

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2366

10/18/2014 Robert Costa

2367

10/18/2014 Alan Liechty

2368

10/18/2014 Theo Tanalski

2369

10/18/2014 Michael Chidester

2370

10/18/2014 Abraham Svoboda

2371

10/18/2014 Zoerab Tchahkiev

2372

10/18/2014 John Aldrich

2373

10/18/2014 Patricia A. Williams

2374

10/18/2014 Stan Sheggeby

2375

10/18/2014 Garrison Clarke

2376

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2377

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2378

10/18/2014 J. Drake

2379

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2380

10/18/2014 Shaun R. Wagner

2381

10/18/2014 Warren Gaspar

2382

10/18/2014 Josephine Dotson

2383

10/18/2014 Carlos C. Campbell 

2384

10/18/2014 Michael

2385

10/18/2014 Phil McIntosh

2386

10/18/2014 June R Genis

2387

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2388

10/18/2014 Adrian Bridge

2389

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2390

10/18/2014 David Alten

2391

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2392

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2393

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2394

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2395

10/18/2014 Georgia Williams

2396

10/18/2014 James Edward Workman

2397

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2398

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2399

10/18/2014 DCI.ltd

2400

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2401

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2402

10/18/2014 Avery Musbach

2403

10/18/2014 Eric Park

2404

10/18/2014 John Savage

2405

10/18/2014 Jessica Kellam

2406

10/18/2014 Stephen Bell

2407

10/18/2014 Larry Maynard

2408

10/18/2014 M. Reed

2409

10/18/2014 James L Panek

2410

10/18/2014 Sterling Robison

2411

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2412

10/18/2014 Jerold M Gorski

2413

10/18/2014 Jordan Wharton

2414

10/18/2014 Ben Hudson

2415

10/18/2014 P G Wade

2416

10/18/2014 Leslie Van Exel

2417

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2418

10/18/2014 Aubrey Champion

2419

10/18/2014 Erik S

2420

10/18/2014 Elias K Gardner

2421

10/18/2014 William Cannon

2422

10/18/2014 Miki Foster

2423

10/18/2014 Richard W. Kelly

2424

10/18/2014 Christopher Triplett

2425

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2426

10/18/2014 Max Lent

2427

10/18/2014 Terry Neckar

2428

10/18/2014 Ilma Raupp

2429

10/18/2014 D. Knipp

2430

10/18/2014 Paul Schmidtke

2431

10/18/2014 John Larson

2432

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2433

10/18/2014 Gregory Walker

2434

10/18/2014 David Walker

2435

10/18/2014 Domenic DiGirolamo

2436

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2437

10/18/2014 Ferdinand Harmsen

2438

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2439

10/18/2014 David Aderton

2440

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2441

10/18/2014 Mahyar Mohammadi

2442

10/18/2014 Thomas Willson

2443

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2444

10/18/2014 Ariah Kidder

2445

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2446

10/18/2014 Jack Bates

2447

10/18/2014 Gary

2448

10/18/2014 Ryan Wichterich

2449

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2450

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2451

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2452

10/18/2014 Neal Groothuis

2453

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2454

10/18/2014 Robert E. Rutkowski

2455

10/18/2014 Jon Thompson

2456

10/18/2014 Chris Santos

2457

10/18/2014 Roxanne Boyle

2458

10/18/2014 Ben Golden

2459

10/18/2014 Matthew Tambio

2460

10/18/2014 Ross De Groot

2461

10/18/2014 Roger H. Johnson

2462

10/18/2014 Mike Tessier

2463

10/18/2014 Russel Brooks

2464

10/18/2014 LuRetta Fairman

2465

10/18/2014 Patrick Gremo

2466

10/18/2014 Israel Estrada

2467

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2468

10/18/2014 Jeff Schroeder

2469

10/18/2014 Mavis Mather

2470

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2471

10/18/2014 Alan Taranti

2472

10/18/2014 Mois Nathan

2473

10/18/2014 Alex

2474

10/18/2014 Christian Page

2475

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2476

10/18/2014 Tom Oscar

2477

10/18/2014 Troy Unverdruss

2478

10/18/2014 Tyler Acorn

2479

10/18/2014 GK

2480

10/18/2014 Doron Chaim Holcberg

2481

10/18/2014 Stephen Hofstatter

2482

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2483

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2484

10/18/2014 Wilson Smith

2485

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2486

10/18/2014 Sean Wayland

2487

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2488

10/18/2014 Arthur Marble

2489

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2490

10/18/2014 Felipe Vazquez

2491

10/18/2014 Arjan Dekkers

2492

10/18/2014 Carole Craven

2493

10/18/2014 Andrew Wheeler

2494

10/18/2014 Abrar Qureshi

2495

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2496

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2497

10/18/2014 Petr Volf

2498

10/18/2014 Matthew Conlen

2499

10/18/2014 Paul

2500

10/18/2014 Satcatcher

Previous page | Next page

Updated 06/24/2015

 

Link to DFS Portal

About DFS

Contact DFS

Reports & Publications

Licensing

Laws and Regs

Connect With DFS

DFS Facebook page

Follow NYDFS on Twitter