Skip to Content

Comments Regarding the Proposed Virtual Currency Regulatory Framework

The New York State Department of Financial Services published a proposed virtual currency regulatory framework in the July 23, 2014 edition of the New York State Register. A revised proposed virtual currency regulatory framework was published in the February 25, 2015 edition of the New York State Register.

Links to all formal comments submitted during the comment periods are below. Comments are identified by the name signed to each comment. Where no signature was provided, the comment is labeled as unsigned.

Contact and transmittal information for commenters has been redacted. Otherwise, the text of each comment remains unaltered.

0 - 500 | 501 - 1000 | 1001 - 1500 | 1501 - 2000 | 2001 - 2500 | 2501 - 3000 | 3001 - 3500 | 3501 - 3748 | 3749 - 3781

Comment # (PDF) Date Submitted Name of Commenter

2501

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2502

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2503

10/18/2014 Ben Weibel

2504

10/18/2014 Joseph Matthew

2505

10/18/2014 K. Arnone

2506

10/18/2014 Ari

2507

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2508

10/18/2014 Ruth Brissenden

2509

10/18/2014 Max Aller

2510

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2511

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2512

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2513

10/18/2014 Tracey Fleming

2514

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2515

10/18/2014 Claudia Lamparter

2516

10/18/2014 Andre Danylevich

2517

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2518

10/18/2014 Theresa Rogers

2519

10/18/2014 Aeron Danann

2520

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2521

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2522

10/18/2014 Gene Hudnall

2523

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2524

10/18/2014 Jimmy Wu

2525

10/18/2014 John Space

2526

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2527

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2528

10/18/2014 Kalin Yancy

2529

10/18/2014 David Lowenfels

2530

10/18/2014 Devin Goddard

2531

10/18/2014 Storm Thomas

2532

10/18/2014 Andy Melville

2533

10/18/2014 Virginia Kindig

2534

10/18/2014 Bob Chalmers

2535

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2536

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2537

10/18/2014 Brett Goldstock

2538

10/18/2014 Chance Catucci

2539

10/18/2014 Cliff Jones

2540

10/18/2014 Mateusz Konieczny

2541

10/18/2014 Jim O'Flaherty Jr.

2542

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2543

10/18/2014 Per Guth

2544

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2545

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2546

10/18/2014 Jason Fracaro

2547

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2548

10/18/2014 Walter Fruge

2549

10/18/2014 Patrice Hermenault

2550

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2551

10/18/2014 Alfonso Martinez

2552

10/18/2014 Casey Williams

2553

10/18/2014 Nicholas Atkinson

2554

10/18/2014 Andrew Olsen

2555

10/18/2014 Levi King

2556

10/18/2014 Jacob Whitford-Bender

2557

10/18/2014 Diane Hendricks

2558

10/18/2014 Andy Papa

2559

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2560

10/18/2014 John Shale

2561

10/18/2014 Pablo Edgardo Cano Gifford

2562

10/18/2014 Timothy Spong

2563

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2564

10/18/2014 Josiah Knoll

2565

10/18/2014 Leonard Herman

2566

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2567

10/18/2014 Tim Smith

2568

10/18/2014 Matthew Hales

2569

10/18/2014 Bernard D. Clendenin

2570

10/18/2014 Douglas & Claudia Reid

2571

10/18/2014 Radoslav I

2572

10/18/2014 Andrew Peter Steingass

2573

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2574

10/18/2014 Vito Matijevic

2575

10/18/2014 Marie Elena Yslas Castro

2576

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2577

10/18/2014 Joel Corey

2578

10/18/2014 Estefania

2579

10/18/2014 Brian Lingard

2580

10/18/2014 Tom

2581

10/18/2014 Gabriel Jourdenais Hamel

2582

10/18/2014 Andrew Sun

2583

10/18/2014 Andrew Chin

2584

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2585

10/18/2014 Noel Pamintuan

2586

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2587

10/18/2014 Damian Johnson

2588

10/18/2014 Collin Moore

2589

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2590

10/18/2014 Jonatas Esteves Silverio

2591

10/18/2014 Cory J. Woodbury

2592

10/18/2014 Bruce Gehiere

2593

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2594

10/18/2014 Francis James Roberts

2595

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2596

10/18/2014 Luke

2597

10/18/2014 Patrick O'Doherty

2598

10/18/2014 Ben Beetle

2599

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2600

10/18/2014 Paul Ferguson

2601

10/18/2014 Francine Burke

2602

10/18/2014 Joseph Carr

2603

10/18/2014 Kavita

2604

10/18/2014 Nick Spence

2605

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2606

10/18/2014 TJ

2607

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2608

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2609

10/18/2014 Nick Kampe

2610

10/18/2014 Christian Areas

2611

10/18/2014 Ed Lucas

2612

10/18/2014 Kermit Beasley

2613

10/18/2014 Christopher Malon

2614

10/18/2014 Ryan Bertee

2615

10/18/2014 Victor G. Muñoz Mijares

2616

10/18/2014 Robert Orynich

2617

10/18/2014 Rob D

2618

10/18/2014 Anthony Minton

2619

10/18/2014 Dave Doering

2620

10/18/2014 Michael Hutchinson

2621

10/18/2014 John Jeffress

2622

10/18/2014 Stephen Barker

2623

10/18/2014 James Linder

2624

10/18/2014 B. Nolan Nichols

2625

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2626

10/18/2014 Dave Cardosi

2627

10/18/2014 Joshua Deighton

2628

10/18/2014 Doug Wright

2629

10/18/2014 David Lipfert

2630

10/18/2014 Christopher Scanga

2631

10/18/2014 Robert Jenkins

2632

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2633

10/18/2014 Jeremy Thompson

2634

10/18/2014 Frank Shinneman

2635

10/18/2014 Howard Shapiro

2636

10/18/2014 Bo King

2637

10/18/2014 John Krumpotick

2638

10/18/2014 David L Ballenger

2639

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2640

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2641

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2642

10/18/2014 Sergio Rodriguez

2643

10/18/2014 Dezponia Veil

2644

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2645

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2646

10/18/2014 Teresa C Jacobs

2647

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2648

10/18/2014 Phil Ewing

2649

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2650

10/18/2014 Faisal Kabir

2651

10/18/2014 Roger Hartman

2652

10/18/2014 Chad Hillesland

2653

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2654

10/18/2014 Sergey Prokushkin

2655

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2656

10/18/2014 India White

2657

10/18/2014 Charlie Goldberg

2658

10/18/2014 Joe Pasqualetti

2659

10/18/2014 Ken Schultz

2660

10/18/2014 Scott F. Comstock

2661

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2662

10/18/2014 Donnncha O'Cearbhaill

2663

10/18/2014 Jeff Abrahamson

2664

10/19/2014 Unsigned

2665

10/19/2014 John D. Harlan

2666

10/19/2014 Kevin L. Meyer

2667

10/19/2014 Unsigned

2668

10/19/2014 Unsigned

2669

10/19/2014 Heidi Schmitt-Irlinger

2670

10/19/2014 Sanda Jovanovic

2671

10/19/2014 Unsigned

2672

10/19/2014 Makaainanastyle

2673

10/19/2014 Marius Nastasenko

2674

10/19/2014 Bert van Hoogenhuyze

2675

10/19/2014 John Kinney

2676

10/19/2014 Christian Damken

2677

10/19/2014 Unsigned

2678

10/19/2014 Arthur Lampert

2679

10/19/2014 Steven Caskey

2680

10/19/2014 Spencer

2681

10/19/2014 David Key

2682

10/21/2014 Daniel Brennan

2683

10/21/2014 Allan Wright

2684

10/21/2014 Unsigned

2685

10/21/2014 Jenna

2686

10/21/2014 Ben Metcalfe

2687

10/21/2014 Unsigned

2688

10/21/2014 Seth McClain

2689

10/21/2014 Unsigned

2690

10/21/2014 Tiago Egas Costa

2691

10/21/2014 Unsigned

2692

10/21/2014 Theodore K.

2693

10/21/2014 Unsigned

2694

10/21/2014 Ander GB

2695

10/21/2014 Unsigned

2696

10/21/2014 Unsigned

2697

10/21/2014 Mike Niccum

2698

10/21/2014 Timothy C. Brandt

2699

10/21/2014 Greg Garrett

2700

10/21/2014 Unsigned

2701

10/21/2014 Brian Kroll

2702

10/18/2014 Xane Myers

2703

10/18/2014 Ole Nielson

2704

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2705

10/18/2014 Jacob Fox

2706

10/18/2014 Sylvester

2707

10/18/2014 Sheila Goods

2708

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2709

10/18/2014 Robert G. Patocka

2710

10/18/2014 Josh Koch

2711

10/18/2014 Anna Marrie

2712

10/18/2014 Kim Post

2713

10/18/2014 Marion Young

2714

10/18/2014 Tim McCormack

2715

10/18/2014 Jason Mauch

2716

10/18/2014 Sarah A. Morrigan

2717

10/18/2014 Chuck Kasper

2718

10/18/2014 Daniel Marston

2719

10/18/2014 Scott Bentley

2720

10/18/2014 Stephen Rozzo

2721

10/18/2014 Alex Eagle

2722

10/18/2014 Trent Sikes

2723

10/18/2014 Christopher Kline

2724

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2725

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2726

10/18/2014 Richard C. Grimshaw

2727

10/18/2014 Kathy Noble

2728

10/18/2014 Theresa J. Titus

2729

10/18/2014 Dave Yuriar

2730

10/18/2014 Anthony

2731

10/18/2014 Aimé M.

2732

10/18/2014 Libby J. Goldstein

2733

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2734

10/18/2014 Paul Kopacki

2735

10/18/2014 Daniel Warner

2736

10/18/2014 Patrick Cherry

2737

10/18/2014 Adfeno

2738

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2739

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2740

10/18/2014 John

2741

10/18/2014 Darrell Budic

2742

10/18/2014 Taylor Johnson

2743

10/18/2014 Steve Jones

2744

10/18/2014 Claudia Bassi

2745

10/18/2014 Kathryn Melton

2746

10/18/2014 Jon Hartwell

2747

10/18/2014 Christopher Ursich

2748

10/18/2014 Steve Smallwood

2749

10/18/2014 Sergey S. Ermolenko

2750

10/18/2014 Adrian Ryniec

2751

10/18/2014 Ron

2752

10/18/2014 Geno Burch

2753

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2754

10/18/2014 Lawrence Fine

2755

10/18/2014 Artem Nikulkov

2756

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2757

10/18/2014 Frank Schmeisser

2758

10/18/2014 James Phillip Turpin

2759

10/18/2014 James Glaccum

2760

10/18/2014 Kaylin Greene

2761

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2762

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2763

10/18/2014 Steven Hand

2764

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2765

10/18/2014 Baltasar Cevc

2766

10/18/2014 James P. Higgins

2767

10/18/2014 Zachary Ross

2768

10/18/2014 Kyoshin Harrower

2769

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2770

10/18/2014 John H. Loftus

2771

10/18/2014 Mario Halkyer

2772

10/18/2014 Daniel Coley

2773

10/18/2014 Tim Do

2774

10/18/2014 Bryan Montford

2775

10/18/2014 Japheth Campbell

2776

10/18/2014 Steven Stanton

2777

10/18/2014 Richard Cone

2778

10/18/2014 Annette Dubois

2779

10/18/2014 RJ Lalumiere

2780

10/18/2014 David Zabkar

2781

10/18/2014 Justin Abrahms

2782

10/18/2014 Jeff Buckley

2783

10/18/2014 Craig King

2784

10/18/2014 Steve Mattan

2785

10/18/2014 Ricardo Frustockl

2786

10/18/2014 Troy Laipply

2787

10/18/2014 Michael Boman

2788

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2789

10/18/2014 Jennifer Stapleton-Kotloski

2790

10/18/2014 Matias Rocha

2791

10/18/2014 Thomas

2792

10/18/2014 Georgia Carbone

2793

10/18/2014 Cathy Atela

2794

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2795

10/18/2014 Gordon Sterling

2796

10/18/2014 Monty

2797

10/18/2014 Carly Marcoux

2798

10/18/2014 Adam Perysian

2799

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2800

10/18/2014 Samuel jones

2801

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2802

10/18/2014 David B. Stevens

2803

10/18/2014 Michael R. Atkins

2804

10/18/2014 Lea Sprenger

2805

10/18/2014 John Brennan

2806

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2807

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2808

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2809

10/18/2014 Concerned Legitimate Bitcoin User

2810

10/18/2014 Brendan Rowe

2811

10/18/2014 Dmitry Erastov

2812

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2813

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2814

10/18/2014 Alec Zopf

2815

10/18/2014 John Franco

2816

10/18/2014 Stephen Cooper

2817

10/18/2014 Charles Tabor

2818

10/18/2014 Joanna Rives

2819

10/18/2014 John Lindsey

2820

10/18/2014 Jeffery Fambrough

2821

10/18/2014 Gareth Yawching-Rickwood

2822

10/18/2014 Christopher Lincoln

2823

10/18/2014 Eduard Ihnat

2824

10/18/2014 Tony Cavanna

2825

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2826

10/18/2014 Mike Toft

2827

10/18/2014 Anthony Woods

2828

10/18/2014 Mohamed ElGohary

2829

10/18/2014 Nathan Guerrero

2830

10/18/2014 Felipe Ortiz

2831

10/18/2014 Matthew Waldrum

2832

10/18/2014 Steve Grandpre

2833

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2834

10/18/2014 Jerry Roedel

2835

10/18/2014 Arsham Skrenes

2836

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2837

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2838

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2839

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2840

10/18/2014 Gaurav Malhotra

2841

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2842

10/18/2014 John P. Simanonok

2843

10/18/2014 Richard Lane

2844

10/18/2014 Thomas Askjellerud

2845

10/18/2014 Ben

2846

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2847

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2848

10/18/2014 Jerrod Dixon

2849

10/18/2014 Dolores Bittner

2850

10/18/2014 Mark Ward

2851

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2852

10/18/2014 Michael Isom

2853

10/18/2014 Andrew Kroll

2854

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2855

10/18/2014 Brad Meyer

2856

10/18/2014 Tristan Hardy

2857

10/18/2014 S Hansen

2858

10/18/2014 Lee Flemm

2859

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2860

10/18/2014 W. Scott Davison

2861

10/18/2014 Matthew Padgett

2862

10/18/2014 Larry Erland

2863

10/18/2014 Mark Creighton

2864

10/18/2014 James Whitescarver

2865

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2866

10/18/2014 Luke Irizarry

2867

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2868

10/18/2014 Rhean Murray

2869

10/18/2014 Harmke Lubbers

2870

10/18/2014 Xavier Bernard

2871

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2872

10/18/2014 Arthur Grau

2873

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2874

10/18/2014 Joseph Kramer

2875

10/18/2014 Sr. Lan Belmont

2876

10/18/2014 Charlie Calhoun

2877

10/18/2014 Peter A. Cummins

2878

10/18/2014 F David Tucker

2879

10/18/2014 Joseph Kohn

2880

10/18/2014 Will Burke

2881

10/18/2014 Ruben A. Espinal

2882

10/18/2014 DodoDude700

2883

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2884

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2885

10/18/2014 Michael Prewitt

2886

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2887

10/18/2014 Sean-Paul Adams

2888

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2889

10/18/2014 Matthew McCormack

2890

10/18/2014 George E. McCain

2891

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2892

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2893

10/18/2014 Joseph Lee Kraft

2894

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2895

10/18/2014 Jeffrey Kane

2896

10/18/2014 Jaime Herazo B.

2897

10/18/2014 Robert Varipapa

2898

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2899

10/18/2014 GA

2900

10/18/2014 Dwyer Deighan

2901

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2902

10/18/2014 Susan Sively

2903

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2904

10/18/2014 Michael Fink

2905

10/18/2014 Augusto Amaral

2906

10/18/2014 Andrew Berg

2907

10/18/2014 Nicholas Muir

2908

10/18/2014 David Ruch

2909

10/18/2014 Kevin Zheng

2910

10/18/2014 Dayle Gomez

2911

10/18/2014 Lorne Covington

2912

10/18/2014 Peter R. Cox

2913

10/18/2014 Dave Hitt

2914

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2915

10/18/2014 Hanna Kutcher

2916

10/18/2014 Jeremy Ginsburg

2917

10/18/2014 Sicco van Sas

2918

10/18/2014 Joshua Rabin

2919

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2920

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2921

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2922

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2923

10/18/2014 David Neal Miller

2924

10/18/2014 Mark T. O'Bryan

2925

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2926

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2927

10/18/2014 Iván Pulido

2928

10/18/2014 Sam Andujar

2929

10/18/2014 Trevor Bergeron

2930

10/18/2014 James Christy

2931

10/18/2014 B. Cavin Lang

2932

10/18/2014 Ms Yav

2933

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2934

10/18/2014 Sean

2935

10/18/2014 Neil Gorter

2936

10/18/2014 Matthew Agen

2937

10/18/2014 Duncan Thomas

2938

10/18/2014 Samuel B. Johnson

2939

10/18/2014 William Arnold

2940

10/18/2014 Alice Bulukin

2941

10/18/2014 Jeff Pettiross

2942

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2943

10/18/2014 Eric W. Wallace

2944

10/18/2014 Nathan Richey

2945

10/18/2014 Michael Ashton

2946

10/18/2014 Anthony Agtuca

2947

10/18/2014 Dawn Jackson

2948

10/18/2014 Frode Lindeijer

2949

10/18/2014 Ryan J. Pelowski

2950

10/18/2014 Randy Gingeleski

2951

10/18/2014 William Spaulding

2952

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2953

10/18/2014 Ismael J. Rodriguez

2954

10/18/2014 Shaun Redmond

2955

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2956

10/18/2014 Brett Williams

2957

10/18/2014 Brennan Nance

2958

10/18/2014 Norman E Rondeau

2959

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2960

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2961

10/18/2014 Lawrence M. Caring

2962

10/18/2014 Unsigned

2963

10/18/2014 Adam Crane

2964

10/18/2014 Adam Crane

2965

10/19/2014 David Skinner

2966

10/19/2014 Macht

2967

10/19/2014 Unsigned

2968

10/19/2014 Unsigned

2969

10/19/2014 Wayne D. Holt

2970

10/19/2014 Donna Browning

2971

10/19/2014 Unsigned

2972

10/19/2014 Jennifer Mercede

2973

10/19/2014 Damian Diaz

2974

10/19/2014 Kenneth A. Carver

2975

10/19/2014 Dane Steinohrt

2976

10/19/2014 Greg Taylor

2977

10/19/2014 Trevor Robinson

2978

10/19/2014 Christopher Gauthreaux

2979

10/19/2014 Larissa Chiriaeva

2980

10/19/2014 Unsigned

2981

10/19/2014 Dean Katz

2982

10/19/2014 Unsigned

2983

10/19/2014 Unsigned

2984

10/19/2014 Cherylynn Costner

2985

10/19/2014 Benjamin Connor

2986

10/19/2014 Oded

2987

10/19/2014 Greg Harold

2988

10/19/2014 Greg Harold

2989

10/19/2014 Michael Vinal

2990

10/19/2014 James. C. Stevens

2991

10/19/2014 Unsigned

2992

10/19/2014 Dany Lindenbacher

2993

10/19/2014 Unsigned

2994

10/19/2014 Jason Flower

2995

10/19/2014 Jorge Torres

2996

10/19/2014 Unsigned

2997

10/19/2014 Unsigned

2998

10/19/2014 Micah

2999

10/19/2014 Ron Unger

3000

10/19/2014 Carson Morrow

Previous page | Next page

Updated 06/24/2015

 

Link to DFS Portal

About DFS

Contact DFS

Reports & Publications

Licensing

Laws and Regs

Connect With DFS

DFS Facebook page

Follow NYDFS on Twitter