Contact Info for New York Auto Insurers
The following is a list of phone numbers and websites interested consumers may use to contact automobile insurance companies. The companies listed make up 90% of the private passenger automobile insurance marketplace (by premium volume) in New York State. Insurers denoted with an asterisk (*) do not offer quotes or the ability to purchase a policy directly through their website.
Information on insurers not listed here may be obtained by contacting licensed insurance agents or brokers.
| Company Name | Telephone Number | Website |
|---|---|---|
|
A. Central Insurance Co. |
800-234-6926 |
|
|
Adirondack Insurance Exchange* |
800-462-2123 |
|
|
Allmerica Financial Alliance Ins Co.* |
800-992-8427 |
|
|
Allstate Fire and Casualty Insurance Co. |
800-255-7828 |
|
|
Allstate Insurance Co.* |
800-255-7828 |
|
|
American States Insurance Co. |
800-699-3534 |
|
|
Amica Mutual Insurance Co. |
800-242-6422 |
|
|
Amica Property and Casualty |
800-242-6422 |
|
|
Chubb National Insurance Co.* |
866-324-8222 |
|
|
Citizens Insurance Co. of America |
800-922-8427 |
|
|
Country-Wide Insurance Co.* |
800-796-9288 |
|
|
Erie Insurance Co. |
800-458-0811 |
|
|
Esurance Insurance Co. |
800-378-7262 |
|
|
Esurance Property and Casualty Insurance Co. |
800-378-7262 |
|
|
Foremost Insurance Co. Grand Rapids Michigan |
888-888-0080 |
|
|
Foremost Signature Insurance Co. |
888-888-0080 |
|
|
Garrison Property and Casualty Insurance Co. |
800-531-8722 |
|
|
GEICO General Insurance Co. |
800-841-3000 |
|
|
GEICO Indemnity Co. |
800-841-3000 |
|
|
Government Employees Insurance Co. |
800-841-3000 |
|
|
Hartford Casualty Insurance Co. |
800-624-5578 |
|
|
Hartford Underwriters Insurance Co. |
800-541-3717 |
|
|
Integon National Insurance Co. |
800-462-2123 |
|
|
Kemper Independence Insurance Co.* |
800-216-6347 |
|
|
Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Co. |
800-699-3534 |
|
|
LM General Insurance Co. |
800-699-3534 |
|
|
LM Insurance Corporation |
800-699-3534 |
|
|
Massachusetts Bay Insurance Co. |
800-922-8427 |
|
|
Metropolitan Casualty Insurance Co. |
844-569-3607 |
|
|
Metropolitan Group Property & Casualty Insurance Co. |
844-569-3607 |
|
|
Mid Century Insurance Co. |
800-493-4917 |
|
|
National General Assurance Co. |
800-462-2123 |
|
|
National General Insurance Co. |
800-462-2123 |
|
|
National General Insurance Online, Inc |
800-462-2123 |
|
|
Nationwide Affinity Insurance Co. of America* |
877-669-6877 |
|
|
Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co.* |
877-669-6877 |
|
|
New South Insurance Co. |
800-462-2123 |
|
|
New York Central Mutual Fire Ins Co. |
800-234-6926 |
|
|
Preferred Mutual Insurance Co.* |
800-333-7642 |
|
|
Progressive Advanced Ins Co. |
800-776-4743 |
|
|
Progressive Casualty Ins Co. |
800-776-4743 |
|
|
Progressive Max Ins Co. |
800-776-4743 |
|
|
Progressive Specialty Ins Co. |
800-776-4743 |
|
|
Property & Casualty Insurance Co. of Hartford |
800-429-4545 |
|
|
State Farm Fire and Casualty Co. |
Agents Listed |
|
|
State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co. |
Agents Listed |
|
|
The Hanover Insurance Co. |
800-922-8427 |
|
|
Travelers Personal Insurance Co. |
866-522-1338 |
|
|
Travelers Personal Security Insurance Co. |
866-522-1338 |
|
|
United Services Automobile Association |
800-531-8222 |
|
|
Unitrin Safeguard Insurance Co. |
800-216-6347 |
|
|
USAA Casualty Insurance Co. |
800-531-8222 |
|
|
USAA General Indemnity Co. |
800-531-8722 |