Surprise Medical Bills, including Bills for Emergency Services
Consumers in New York are protected from:
- Surprise bills when treated by an out-of-network provider at a hospital or ambulatory surgical center in their health plan’s network.
- Surprise bills when an in-network doctor refers them to an out-of-network provider (depending on the type of health insurance coverage they have).
- Bills for emergency services in hospitals, including inpatient care following emergency room treatment.
The following information explains what you need to know about these important protections if:
- you have coverage with an HMO or insurer subject to New York law;
- you have coverage under the New York State Empire Plan or the New York State Student Employee Health Plan that is available to SUNY and CUNY graduate and teaching assistant employees;
- you are uninsured or your employer or union provides self-funded coverage that is not subject to New York law; or
- you are a health care provider.
How to Protect Yourself from a Surprise Medical Bill
If You Have Health Insurance Subject to New York Law
If you have health insurance coverage subject to New York Law (your health insurance ID card says “fully insured” or you are covered under the New York State Empire Plan or the New York State Student Employee Health Plan)
Surprise bills happen when an out-of-network provider treats you at an in-network hospital or ambulatory surgical center OR you are referred by an in-network doctor to an out-of-network provider. (In-network means in your health plan’s network.) You only have to pay your in-network cost-sharing (copayment, coinsurance, or deductible) for a surprise bill.
It’s a Surprise Bill at an In-Network Hospital or Ambulatory Surgical Center if an Out-of-Network Provider Treats You and:
- An in-network provider was not available; OR
- An out-of-network provider provided services without your knowledge; OR
- Unforeseen medical services were provided when you received health care services; OR
- You received emergency medicine, anesthesia, pathology, radiology, laboratory, neonatology, assistant surgeon, hospitalist, or intensivist services.
It is NOT a surprise bill if an in-network provider is available and you choose to receive services from an out-of-network provider (unless the services are emergency medicine, anesthesia, pathology, radiology, laboratory, neonatology, assistant surgeon, hospitalist, or intensivist services). For example, it is not a surprise bill if your health plan sends you a preauthorization determination that the provider is out-of-network before you receive the services or you had a meaningful opportunity to choose an in-network provider 72 hours in advance of the services.
It’s a Surprise Bill when your In-Network Doctor Refers You to an Out-of-Network Provider If:
- You did not sign a written consent that you knew the services were out-of-network and would not be covered by your health plan; AND
- During a visit with your in-network doctor, an out-of-network provider treats you; OR
- Your in-network doctor takes a specimen from you in the office (for example, blood) and sends it to an out-of-network laboratory or pathologist; OR
- For any other health care services when referrals are required under your plan.
If You Get a Surprise Bill Because an Out-of-Network Provider Treats you at an In-Network Hospital or Ambulatory Surgical Center OR Your Doctor Refers You to an Out-of-Network Provider:
- You only have to pay your in-network cost-sharing.
- If an out-of-network provider bills you for any amount over your in-network cost-sharing this is called balance-billing.
- If your doctor referred you to an out-of-network provider, you MUST send a Surprise Medical Bill Certification Form to your health plan and your provider to make sure that they know you received a Surprise Bill and that you must be protected from balance billing.
- If an out-of-network provider treats you at an in-network hospital or ambulatory surgical facility, you should send a Surprise Medical Bill Certification Form to your health plan and your provider to make sure that they know you received a Surprise Bill and that you must be protected from balance billing. The form is not required for these services, but it is recommended.
- You may also file a complaint with the Department of Financial Services.
How to Protect Yourself If You Have Employer/Union Self-Funded Coverage
If you have employer/union self-funded coverage (your health insurance ID card says “self-funded” or does not say “fully insured” the Federal No Surprises Act protects you from surprise medical bills from an out-of-network provider in an in-network hospital or ambulatory surgical center if your employer or union self-funds your coverage.
You are only responsible for paying your in-network cost-sharing (copayment, coinsurance, or deductible) for a surprise bill.
For more information about the Federal consumer protections, visit the CMS No Surprises Act website.
Note: I you are covered under the New York State Empire Plan or the New York State Student Employee Health Plan, available to SUNY and CUNY graduate and teaching assistant employees, the New York State surprise bill protections apply to you.
How to Protect Yourself If You Are Uninsured
Good Faith Estimate for Uninsured or Self-Pay Patients
If you are uninsured, or you are insured but you don’t plan to file a claim with your health plan, health care providers must give you a good faith estimate of what their expected charges will be before you get health care services.
Providers must give you the good faith estimate:
- For services scheduled at least 3 business days ahead of time, within 1 business day of scheduling the service;
- For services scheduled at least 10 business days ahead of time, within 3 business days of scheduling the service; or
- When you ask for the good faith estimate, within 3 business days of you asking for the estimate.
The good faith estimate will include:
- A description of the service you will be getting;
- A list of other services that are reasonably expected to be provided with the service you are getting;
- The diagnosis and expected service codes; and
- The expected charges for the services.
For more information about good faith estimates, visit the CMS No Surprises Act website.
Patient-Provider Dispute Resolution Process For Good Faith Estimates
If you are billed for an amount that is at least $400 more than the amount on the good faith estimate you got from your health care provider, you (or your authorized representative) may dispute the charges in the Federal patient-provider dispute resolution process. You have to ask for the review within 120 calendar days of getting the bill. An independent reviewer will look at the good faith estimate, the bill, and information from the provider to decide the amount, if any, that you have to pay for each service.
For more information about the patient-provider dispute resolution process, visit the CMS No Surprises Act website.
NYS Patient-Provider Dispute Resolution Process If You Don’t Get A Good Faith Estimate
If your provider doesn’t give you a good faith estimate and you feel the charge is unreasonable, you may qualify for an independent dispute resolution (IDR) through New York State by submitting an IDR application to dispute the bill. To be eligible:
- you receive services from a doctor at a hospital or ambulatory surgical center; and
- you don’t receive all the required information about your care.
See below Information Your Doctor and Other Health Care Professionals Must Give You and Information Your Hospital Must Give You for the information that must be provided to you.
You will have to pay the fee for IDR (up to $495) if your provider’s bill is upheld unless your household income is below 250% of the Federal Poverty Level.
To Apply. Complete an IDR Patient Application and send it to the New York State Department of Financial Services, Consumer Assistance Unit/IDR Process, One Commerce Plaza, Albany, NY 12257.
Information your Doctor/Health Care Professionals Must Give You
Your doctor and other health care professionals, including a group practice of providers, a diagnostic and treatment center, and a health center must give patients and prospective patients the following information:
- Health Plan Networks. The health plans in which your provider is in-network. This must be given to you in writing or through a website before you receive non-emergency services and verbally when you schedule an appointment.
- Hospital Affiliations. The hospitals that your provider is affiliated with or that could admit you. This must be given to you in writing or through a website before you receive non-emergency services and verbally when you schedule an appointment.
- Cost of Services. If your provider is not in-network with your health plan, your provider must tell you the estimated amount your provider will bill you for services if you ask.
- Providers Scheduled by Your Doctor. If your doctor schedules anesthesiology, laboratory, pathology, radiology, or assistant surgeon services to be provided in your doctor's office or refers you for these services, your doctor must tell you:
- The provider's name, if your doctor schedules a certain provider in a practice.
- The name of the provider's practice.
- The provider's address.
- The provider's telephone number.
- When Your Doctor Schedules Your Hospital Services. If your doctor schedules any other doctors to treat you in a hospital your doctor must tell you:
- The doctor's name.
- The doctor's practice.
- The doctor's address.
- The doctor's telephone number.
- How to determine whether the doctor is in-network with your health plan.
Information your Hospital Must Give You
Hospitals must post on their websites:
- Charges. A list of their charges (or how you can get this information if the list of charges is not posted).
- Health Plan Networks. The health plans in which they are in-network.
- Information About Charges Of Doctors In The Hospital:
- Services provided to you by doctors in the hospital are not included in the hospital's charges.
- Doctors who provide services in the hospital may or may not be in the same health plan networks as the hospital.
- You should ask the doctor arranging your hospital services if the doctor is in your health plan's network.
- Doctors That Could Provide Services to You. The name, address, and telephone number of the doctor groups that the hospital has contracted with to provide services (such as anesthesiology, pathology, or radiology) and instructions how to contact these groups to determine if they are in your health plan’s network.
- Doctors Employed By The Hospital. The name, address, and telephone number of doctors employed by the hospital to treat patients and the health care plans where they are in-network.
Hospitals must, in registration or admission materials that they give you before non-emergency hospital services:
- Tell You To Contact Your Doctor. Tell you to check with the doctor arranging your hospital services to determine:
- The name, practice name, address, and telephone number of any other doctor who your doctor will ask to treat you.
- If doctors who are employed or contracted by the hospital for services such as anesthesiology, pathology, and radiology are expected to treat you.
- How to Tell If Your Doctor is In-Network. Tell you how to find out if doctors who are employees of the hospital (such as for anesthesiology, pathology, and radiology) are in-network with your health plan.
Emergency Services - How To Protect Yourself
If You Have Health Insurance Coverage Subject To New York Law
If You Have Health Insurance Coverage Subject To New York Law (your health insurance ID card says “fully insured” or you are covered under the New York State Empire Plan or the New York State Student Employee Health Plan)
You only have to pay your in-network cost-sharing (copayment, coinsurance, or deductible) for bills for out-of-network emergency services in a hospital.
- This includes bills from doctors, the hospital, and any other providers who treat you.
- This includes inpatient services if you are admitted to the hospital after your emergency room visit.
- Your provider may only bill you for your in-network cost-sharing for emergency services, including inpatient services that follow an emergency room visit.
- Let your health plan know if you receive a bill from an out-of-network provider for emergency services.
- You may also file a complaint with the Department of Financial Services.
If You Have Employer/Union Self-Funded Coverage
If You Have Employer/Union Self-Funded Coverage (your health insurance ID card says “self-funded” or does not say “fully insured”)
The Federal No Surprises Act protects you from bills for out-of-network emergency services if your employer or union self-funds your coverage. This includes inpatient care following emergency room treatment.
You are only responsible for paying your in-network cost-sharing (copayment, coinsurance, or deductible) for emergency services.
For more information about the Federal consumer protections, visit the CMS No Surprises Act website.
Note: If you are covered under the New York State Empire Plan or the New York State Student Employee Health Plan that is available to SUNY and CUNY graduate and teaching assistant employees, the New York State surprise bill protections for emergency services apply to you.
If You Are Uninsured
If you are uninsured, you may file a dispute through the New York State independent dispute resolution (IDR) process if you receive a bill for emergency services in New York that you believe is excessive. You will have to pay the fee for the IDR (up to $495) if your provider’s bill is upheld unless your household income is below 250% of the Federal Poverty Level.
Complete an IDR Patient Application and send it to the New York State Department of Financial Services, Consumer Assistance Unit/IDR Process, One Commerce Plaza, Albany, NY 12257.
Information for Health Care Providers
If a Patient has Insurance Coverage Subject to NY Law
If a Patient has Insurance Coverage Subject to NY Law (coverage that is not self-funded or coverage under the New York State Empire Plan or the New York State Student Employee Health Plan)
You may only bill your patient for their in-network cost-sharing (copayment, coinsurance, or deductible) for a Surprise Bill in a Hospital or Ambulatory Surgical Center or for a Surprise Bill When Your Patient Received A Referral. Health plans must pay out-of-network providers directly for a surprise bill.
A Bill For Services In a Hospital or Ambulatory Surgical Center is a Surprise Bill If:
Your patient receives services from an out-of-network provider at an in-network hospital or ambulatory surgical center and:
- an in-network provider was not available; or
- an out-of-network provider provided services without your patient's knowledge; or
- unforeseen medical circumstances arose at the time the health care services were provided.
It is NOT a surprise bill when an in-network provider was available, and the patient elected to obtain services from an out-of-network provider.
Providers must give patients all notices required under the No Surprises Act and Public Health Law regarding scheduled services.
Patients must have a meaningful opportunity to choose an in-network provider at least 72 hours in advance of the services. Notice on the day of the services does not give the patient a meaningful opportunity to choose an in-network provider.
It will not be surprise bill when the patient signs the CMS Standard Written Notice and Consent Form. However, surprise bill protections will apply to emergency medicine, anesthesiology, pathology, radiology, laboratory, neonatology, assistant surgeon, hospitalist, and intensivist services (even if the patient receives written notice that a provider of these services is out-of-network and gives written consent.)
It will not be a surprise bill if the out-of-network service is preauthorized in advance, and the health plan gives the provider and patient notice that the service is out-of-network.
A Bill for Services Referred by an In-Network Doctor to an Out-of-Network Provider is a Surprise Bill if:
Your patient did not sign a written consent acknowledging that the services would be out-of-network and would result in costs not covered by the patient's health plan AND
- During a visit with an in-network doctor, an out-of-network provider treats the patient; or
- The patient's in-network doctor takes a specimen from the patient in the office (for example, blood) and sends it to an out-of-network laboratory or pathologist; or
- For any other health care services when referrals are required under the patient's plan.
Surprise Bill Certification Form
An out-of-network provider may ask their patient to sign a Surprise Medical Bill Certification Form at the time that services are provided. An out-of-network provider must send a copy to the patient’s health plan. For services at an in-network hospital or ambulatory surgical center, an out-of-network provider can sign the Surprise Medical Bill Certification Form and send it to the health plan.
Disclosure of Balance Billing Protections
Providers must make publicly available (post in the provider’s office, post on their public websites, and provide to patients), a one-page notice in clear and understandable language containing information on:
- The Federal requirements and prohibitions relating to prohibitions on balance billing for emergency services and surprise bills;
- New York requirements prohibiting balancing billing for emergency services and surprise bills; and
- Information on how to contact New York and Federal agencies in case an individual believes that a provider has violated any state or Federal prohibitions on balance billing for emergency services and surprise bills.
Model Disclosure Form
DFS has a model disclosure form Your Rights and Protections Against Surprise Medical Bills (PDF) that providers can use that will satisfy these disclosure requirements.
IDR Application
Submit an Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR).
- Log onto the DFS portal to obtain a case number:
- Complete the IDR Provider and Insurer Application; AND
- Send the application to the assigned Independent Dispute Resolution Entity (IDRE)
- Include the full IDR fee for the assigned IDRE.
The IDRE will send you information on how to submit the fee. The IDRE Fee Chart is as follows:
| Type of Fee | HHC Group | Kepra d/b/a IMEDICS | Maximus Inc. | MCMC Services, LLC | ProPeer Resources, LLC |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full IDR Fee | 425 | 395 | 375 | 300 | 495 |
| Ineligible/Processing Fee | 175 | 150 | 145 | 100 | 175 |
| Settlement | 275 | 250 | 215 | 175 | 300 |
The IDRE will refund the IDR fee to the prevailing party within 30 days of the determination. If there is a settlement between the two parties or a split decision, a prorated fee applies and both parties will receive a partial refund. If an IDR dispute is determined to be ineligible, an application processing fee may apply resulting in a partial refund.
If a Patient Is Uninsured
If your patient is uninsured, a bill will be a surprise bill if services are provided by a doctor at a hospital or ambulatory surgical center, and the patient is not given all the required information about their care.
- See Information Your Doctor and Other Health Care Professionals Must Give You and Information Your Hospital Must Give You below for a list of the information that must be provided to patients.
In such cases, your patient may dispute the amount of the bill through the New York State Independent Dispute Resolution process.
If A Patient Has Employer/Union Self-Funded Coverage
The Federal No Surprises Act protections from surprise medical bills from an out-of-network provider in an in-network hospital or ambulatory surgical center apply if your patient has employer or union self-funded coverage. Your patient is only responsible for paying their in-network cost-sharing (copayment, coinsurance, or deductible) for a surprise bill.
For more information about the Federal IDR process for surprise bills visit the CMS No Surprises Act website.
Note: If a patient is covered under the New York State Empire Plan or the New York State Student Employee Health Plan, available to SUNY and CUNY graduate and teaching assistant employees, New York State surprise bill protections apply.
Emergency Services Bills
If a Patient has Health Insurance Coverage Subject to NY Law
If a Patient has Health Insurance Coverage Subject to NY Law (not self-funded or your patient is covered under the New York State Empire Plan or the New York State Student Employee Health Plan):
When You Bill A Patient. If you are an out-of-network provider that provided emergency services in a hospital, including inpatient services that follow an emergency room visit, you are prohibited from billing a patient for any amount over their in-network cost-sharing (copayment, coinsurance, or deductible).
Payment for emergency services. Health plans are required to pay out-of-network providers directly for emergency services.
Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR). Health care providers (including hospitals) that are not in a health plan’s network may dispute the amount they are paid by the health plan for emergency services in a hospital, including payment for inpatient services that follow an emergency room visit, through the New York State independent dispute resolution process.
Submit an Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR).
- Log onto the DFS portal to obtain a case number:
- Complete the IDR Provider and Insurer Application; AND
- Send the Application to your assigned Independent Dispute Resolution Entity (IDRE).
- Include the full IDR fee for the assigned IDRE.
The IDRE will send you information on how to submit the fee. The IDRE Fee Chart is as follows:
| Type of Fee | HHC Group | Kepra d/b/a IMEDICS | Maximus Inc. | MCMC Services, LLC | ProPeer Resources, LLC |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full IDR Fee | 425 | 395 | 375 | 300 | 495 |
| Ineligible/Processing Fee | 175 | 150 | 145 | 100 | 175 |
| Settlement | 275 | 250 | 215 | 175 | 300 |
The IDRE will refund the IDR fee to the prevailing party within 30 days of the determination. If there is a settlement between the two parties or a split decision, a prorated fee applies and both parties will receive a partial refund. If an IDR dispute is determined to be ineligible, an application processing fee may apply resulting in a partial refund.
If A Patient Has Employer/Union Self-Funded Coverage
The Federal No Surprises Act protections from bills for emergency services apply if your patient has employer or union self-funded coverage. Your patient is only responsible for paying their in-network cost-sharing (copayment, coinsurance, or deductible) for emergency services.
For more information about the Federal IDR process for emergency services visit the CMS No Surprises Act website.
Note: If your patient is covered under the New York State Empire Plan or the New York State Student Employee Health Plan, available to SUNY and CUNY graduate and teaching assistant employees, the New York State surprise bill protections for emergency services apply.
If a Patient Is Uninsured
Your patient may dispute the amount of the bill through the New York State IDR process.
Air Ambulance Bills
If air ambulance services are covered under a consumer’s health plan, the consumer is only responsible for their in-network cost-sharing, even if the service is from an out-of-network provider.
The air ambulance provider and health plan can negotiate the total payment amount. If the provider and health plan don’t agree on a payment amount, the health plan or provider may send a dispute to CMS under the Federal independent dispute resolution process. For more information, visit the CMS No Surprises Act website.
Submit a Dispute
For health care providers to start the IDR process:
- Log onto the DFS portal to obtain a case number;
- Complete the IDR Provider and Insurer Application;
- send the application to the assigned Independent Dispute Resolution Entity (IDRE).
- Include the full IDR fee for the assigned IDRE.
The IDRE will send you information on how to submit the fee. The IDRE Fee Chart is as follows:
| Type of Fee | HHC Group | Kepra d/b/a IMEDICS | Maximus Inc. | MCMC Services, LLC | ProPeer Resources, LLC |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full IDR Fee | 425 | 395 | 375 | 300 | 495 |
| Ineligible/Processing Fee | 175 | 150 | 145 | 100 | 175 |
| Settlement | 275 | 250 | 215 | 175 | 300 |
The IDRE will refund the IDR fee to the prevailing party within 30 days of the determination. If there is a settlement between the two parties or a split decision, a prorated fee applies and both parties will receive a partial refund. If an IDR dispute is determined to be ineligible, an application processing fee may apply resulting in a partial refund.
Review Of Disputes
Disputes are reviewed by independent dispute resolution entities (IDREs). Decisions will be made by a reviewer with training and experience in health care billing and reimbursement in consultation with a licensed physician in active practice in the same or similar specialty as the physician providing the service that is the subject of the dispute.
45-Day Timeframe. The IDRE will make a determination within 45 business days of receipt of all information the IDRE determines that it needs to review the dispute, including payment of the IDRE’s charge for a full review. Parties to the dispute must submit all necessary information with their IDR application and immediately when contacted by the IDRE, or the information will not be considered.
IDRE Determines the Fee. For disputes involving health plans, the IDRE chooses either the out-of-network provider’s bill or the health plan’s payment. For disputes submitted by uninsured patients, the IDRE determines the fee.
The IDRE Considers These Factors When Making a Determination for Disputes*:
- Whether there is a gross disparity between the fee charged by the provider and (1) fees paid to the provider for the same services provided to other patients in health care plans in which the provider is out-of-network, and (2) the fees paid by the health plan to reimburse similarly qualified out-of-network providers for the same services in the same region;
- The provider's training, education, experience, and usual charge for comparable services when the provider does not participate with the patient's health plan;
- In the case of a hospital, the teaching status, scope of services, and case mix;
- The circumstances and complexity of the case;
- Patient characteristics;
- The median of the rate recognized by the health plan to reimburse similarly qualified providers for the same or similar services in the same region that are participating with the health plan;
- For physician services, the usual and customary cost of the service; and
- Any other information the health plan, physician, or hospital submits.
(*These factors apply to disputes involving the New York State Empire Plan or the New York State Student Employee Health Plan only with respect to a physician who is employed by a general hospital licensed under Public Health Law Article 28 or such hospital’s affiliated medical school or who is part of a group practice that is established as a captive professional services corporation whose shareholders are employees of such hospital.)
IDRE Considers These Factors When Making a Determination for Disputes Involving the New York State Empire Plan or the New York State Student Employee Health Plan*:
- The IDRE must select either the health plan’s payment or the provider’s fee, depending on which one is closest to the allowed benchmark of the 50th percentile of all allowed amounts for the particular health care service performed by an in-network provider in the same or similar specialty and provided in the same geographical area as reported in a benchmarking database maintained by a nonprofit organization specified by the Superintendent of Financial Services (i.e., FAIR Health).
- However, the IDRE may choose the health plan’s payment or the provider’s fee if it is not closest to the allowed benchmark when the health plan’s payment or the provider’s fee are equally distant from the allowed benchmark, or the IDRE determines that the allowed benchmark is not appropriate, based on any of the following information submitted by either party:
- The level of training, education, and experience of the provider, and in the case of a hospital, the teaching staff, scope of services, and case mix;
- The circumstances and complexity of the particular case, including time and place of the service; or
- Individual patient characteristics.
If the IDRE determines that the provider’s fee is reasonable, the amount owed by the health plan will not exceed the 80th percentile of all allowed amounts for the particular health care service performed by an in-network provider in the same or similar specialty and provided in the same geographical area as reported in a benchmarking database maintained by a nonprofit organization specified by the Superintendent of Financial Services (i.e., FAIR Health).
(*These provisions do not apply with respect to a physician who is employed by a general hospital licensed under Public Health Law Article 28 or such hospital’s affiliated medical school or who is part of a group practice that is established as a captive professional services corporation whose shareholders are employees of such hospital. See the other IDRE factors above.)
IDRE may direct a good faith negotiation for settlement. In cases when settlement is likely, or if the health plan's payment and the provider's fee are unreasonably far apart, the IDRE may direct the parties to negotiate.
Review is Binding. The review is binding but admissible in court.
Payment For Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR)
For disputes between a provider and a health plan involving an insured patient (including patients covered under the New York State Empire Plan or the New York State Student Employee Health Plan):
- The provider and health plan must submit full payment for the IDR process upon submission of the IDR application or, if the responding party, when responding to the IDRE’s request for eligibility information and supporting documents.
- The IDRE must issue a refund of the IDR process payment to the prevailing party or, in the case of a settlement or split decision, the pro-rated amount to both parties, within 30 calendar days of making a determination on the dispute or to the applicant within 30 calendar days of rejecting the dispute as ineligible.
- There may be a minimal fee to the provider or health plan submitting the dispute if the dispute is found ineligible or incomplete.
For disputes involving an uninsured patient or a patient covered under a self-funded plan (other than the New York State Empire Plan or the New York State Student Employee Health Plan):
- Payments are due to an IDRE within 30 calendar days from receipt of the IDRE’s written determination and bill.
- The provider pays the cost of the dispute resolution when the IDRE determines that the provider’s fee is not reasonable.
- The patient pays the cost of the dispute resolution when the IDRE determines that provider’s fee is reasonable, unless it would pose a hardship to the patient. "Hardship" means a household income below 250% of the Federal Poverty Level.
Questions About IDR
If you have questions about IDR, or need help completing an application, call (800) 342-3736 or email [email protected].
When possible, include the date(s) of service because different laws and processes may apply depending on when you received the services.